Stephanie Yeaton Gardner

We had a first-rate experience working with Stephanie Yeaton to buy our house on Great Pond! After vacationing on the lake for years, we started exploring buying a home. Even when we were only in the exploration stage, Stephanie made sure she understood what we were looking for and sent us listings that matched our criteria. It took us a few years, but she persisted and when the "stars aligned" she helped us through every step of the buying process. Her extensive network of professionals in the [...]

Stephanie helped us sell our home in Rome in summer 2025. She was a true professional, always responsive, kept us informed and was always on top of everything. We had also requested that she put us in touch with a Portside rep in York county and she did so immediately. We ended up with very smooth transactions.  We would highly recommend Stephanie to anyone selling a home. She was very understanding and made a stressful experience so much easier. 

Stephanie became our realtor “randomly” when we were in the market for a seasonal cabin on Echo Lake. First she was knowledgable about the market in our area, seasonal vs year round, and patiently answered our questions. Our initial home tour was chaotic with our kids and 4 grandkids - but she seemed to enjoy the little kids exploring and pointed out the benefits of the property for our family - she knew all the hidden details of our property! Stephanie helped guide us through the offer and the [...]

"We happily and without hesitation recommend Stephanie to anyone in the area looking to sell or buy, and if we ever move on from our property will hire her again. I fully understand why the seller used her to buy the property and then hired her again when he decided to sell 6 years later. If any prospective buyers/sellers want to contact us for a reference please don’t hesitate." T.A.

“Her knowledge of the people and the area was key to our deciding to purchase a home on Long Pond. She made the process for us, easy and without stress. We couldn’t be happier with our decision and feel lucky that Stephanie was the one to get us started on this journey.”  

Stephanie was OUTSTANDING to work with. My wife and I have been involved in about 20 purchase/sales of commercial and residential properties during our 25 years together.  Both of us have said hands down Stephanie is the best broker either of us have worked with.  She went way above expectations while anticipating what we needed before we even realized it ourselves; communicated promptly, clearly, and efficiently; never balked at any request we made; and made us feel part of the Belgrade [...]

I highly recommend Stephanie Yeaton Gardner as a real estate agent. She was very attentive and professional. She helped us purchase a piece of land on Hoyts Island in Belgrade Lakes and we are thrilled. I am a real estate broker associate myself in New Jersey and can tell you that Stephanie was an excellent agent. She will always have your best interest in mind!

"When we decided to sell our property on Great Pond, there was no question that we would select Stephanie as our listing agent.  We have known her personally and professionally for over 10 years.  Throughout that time, her knowledge of Belgrade Lakes, professionalism and communication have always been excellent.  Since we live so far away, we needed someone we could trust to manage the sale from start to finish while keeping us in the loop.  Stephanie lived up to our expectations and made the [...]

"Stephanie has been my real estate agent since 2013 in the Belgrade Lakes. I’ve worked with many professionals in the real estate world and Stephanie has been a shining star in that role for me. She has represented me twice on properties in the Belgrade lakes region and her guidance and expertise were outstanding on both transactions. She knows how to deal with sensitive issues that come up in negotiations and does so with a calm and sensible demeanor that truly helps “seal deals”.   " I [...]